Opinion Sanders’s single-payer plan overpromises on health care — again

00:31  14 september  2017
00:31  14 september  2017 Source:   The Hill

Sanders single-payer bill poses dilemma for 2020 Dem hopefuls

  Sanders single-payer bill poses dilemma for 2020 Dem hopefuls Sen. Bernie Sanders's (I-Vt.)'s Medicare for all plan has become a key test for Democrats with 2020 presidential ambitions. Sanders, who energized liberals with his improbable run at the White House last year, is poised to introduce a long-awaited single-payer bill when Congress returns to Washington this month. The liberal icon insists it's not a litmus test for the Democrats, but he's actively seeking endorsements. Outside liberal groups are watching closely, with some hinging their own endorsements on a candidate's support for the Sanders health-care model. Sen. Kamala Harris (D-Calif.

America has arguably the best quality of health - care services available in the world, but many Americans Sanders wisely bases his single - payer plan on Medicare because the program has high satisfaction ratings and has traditionally been able to sweep its budgetary problems under the rug.

Sanders ' s long-awaited health care plan is, by turns, vague and unrealistic. Hillary Clinton has made a lot of bad arguments about Bernie Sanders ' s support for single - payer .

Sanders’s single-payer plan overpromises on health care — again © Provided by The Hill Sanders’s single-payer plan overpromises on health care — again Americans are familiar with political promises on health care: lower costs, universal coverage, more fairness, more choice and so forth. Sadly, we are also used to these promises being broken, time and time again. But that doesn't stop politicians from making ever-greater promises to create an utopian healthcare system where all Americans get all the care they need without any significant costs or downsides.

The latest such proposal is Sen. Bernie Sanders's "Medicare for all" plan. It would create a single-payer health system where the federal government pays all health bills for all citizens, and it would be funded by trillions of dollars of tax increases. The projected 10-year cost of his plan is $32 trillion. (That's $32,000,000,000,000.)

Obamacare Architect Flips on Single-Payer: 'The Time Has Come'

  Obamacare Architect Flips on Single-Payer: 'The Time Has Come' Bernie Sanders once said it would take "a million years" for Max Baucus to support single-payer. It took less than 10 years."To a single-payer idea? No. Not in a million years," Sanders replied to a C-SPAN interviewer.

How Sanders would pay for single - payer . Sanders ' s team estimates the plan would require an additional .38 trillion a year in revenue. Clinton's campaign has been charging that Sanders ' s health care vision necessarily entails higher taxes on the middle class. Sanders ' s plan is structured

Bernie Sanders ' s single - payer health care plan would cost twice as much as the candidate estimates, according to a new analysis from the Urban Institute's Health Policy Center. The Washington-based, left-leaning think tank estimates that Sanders ' s plan to provide

Although Congress just comprehensively reformed our national health policy in 2010 with the Affordable Care Act, the issue is once again ripe for discussion. America has arguably the best quality of health-care services available in the world, but many Americans across the political spectrum are rightly frustrated with our convoluted health-care payment structure today.

Most Americans do not choose their own insurance plan but accept the one their employer offers, thereby also accepting the provider network associated with the insurance plan. This means we have very little consumer choice. Even then, we don't know what to expect to pay when we consume health services, because in addition to unaffordable (and ever-increasing) insurance premiums, we face additional out-of-pocket costs and unclear, confusing prices.

Warren dismisses Dem divisions as lawmakers rally around single-payer

  Warren dismisses Dem divisions as lawmakers rally around single-payer Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D) dismissed conflict inside the Democratic Party on Friday in a new interview, noting that Democrats are rallying around health care and other issues. Warren told the editorial board of The Republican on Friday that the Democratic Party has found agreement on the idea that health care should be a guaranteed right for all citizens."One party in America said it was OK to roll back health care coverage for 25 million Americans and one party in America thinks that health care is a basic human right -- I'm ready to go on that one," she said Friday.

Bernie Sanders said Sunday he planned to introduce a single - payer health care plan to Congress, inviting Republican leaders to negotiate the measure. “I'm going to introduce a Medicare-for-all single - payer program," Sanders told anchor Dana Bash on CNN' s "State of the Union."

Bernie Sanders (I-VT) is about to put Democrats’ newfound embrace of single - payer health care to the test. This idea — what is typically meant by “ single - payer ” or “Medicare-for-all” — would make it illegal for private insurers to offer basic health insurance plans , except in highly specialized and

But single payer is not the answer. History shows us that projections often underestimate the costs and overestimate the benefits of government healthcare programs.

Take Medicare as an example: Medicare, which began in 1965, was initially expected to cost $9 billion annually by 1990. This initial cost projection was woefully inaccurate. The actual annual cost of the program in 1990 was $67 billion, and last year (2016), the U.S. spent $588 billion on Medicare alone.

Sen. Sanders wisely bases his single-payer plan on Medicare because the program has high satisfaction ratings and has traditionally been able to sweep its budgetary problems under the rug. But a peek under the rug reveals a hole threatening to suck the entire federal budget into it. The program is expected to be bankrupt by 2029.

Medicare's ballooning budget is a concern, and not just for fiscal conservatives on the right. Democrats tacitly admitted Medicare needed budget controls when they passed the Affordable Care Act, which included the Independent Payment Advisory Board or IPAB.

This unelected board will be tasked with reducing per-capita Medicare spending, which will inevitably mean lower reimbursements to health providers for certain services they provide to Medicare-insured seniors.  This will result in backdoor rationing of health services as prices dip below what many providers will accept. The IPAB process has not yet been triggered, but Medicare's actuaries estimate that this will happen in 2021.

The Affordable Care Act has also failed to live up to expectations: This summer, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services updated their per-capita cost projections for the Medicaid expansion to be 50 percent higher than previous projections. And as private insurance premiums continue to rise at double-digit rates each year, so do the costs of the ACA premium-assistance tax credits and subsidies for income-eligible consumers in the exchanges.

Analysis | The dam is now breaking on Democrats’ embrace of single-payer

  Analysis | The dam is now breaking on Democrats’ embrace of single-payer And it's being led by 2020 hopefuls.What do those four senators have in common? Well, they just happen to constitute four  of the eight most likely 2020 Democratic presidential nominees, according to the handy list I put out Friday. And another senator in my top 8, Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.), last month came out in favor of the idea of “Medicare for all” — though not this specific bill (yet).

Single - payer health care is a terrible idea, but Bernie Sanders does us all a favor by proposing it. And he is running hard to the left of Clinton, whose plan for health - care reform in 1993 and 1994 failed largely because it was viewed by voters as too radical and disruptive.

Even on the Democratic side of the aisle, Sanders and McDermott face the challenge of anemic enthusiasm; Mr. Obama rejected the idea of a single - payer health care plan during the debate over his own plan a year ago, and there has been no indication that he has changed his position

The coverage projections for the ACA were also off. The Congressional Budget Office projected that 24 million Americans would enroll in the law's exchanges in 2017. How many people actually did? Only half of that: 12.2 million. The overall coverage figures only appear larger when Medicaid's exploding enrollment is considered.

Of course, there are problems in the way we pay for health insurance, and those lawmakers and advocates who suggest change are doing so with good intentions. We need more choices and lower costs (which will only come as a result of market competition). Single payer would only take us in the opposite direction, eliminating market competition and choice, and driving up costs until the inevitable result - restricted access through rationing. This is the case in other nations with single-payer, and it may soon be the case with Medicare if the IPAB process is triggered.

Given the problems in Medicare, Medicaid, and the Affordable Care Act, Americans should hesitate before falling for yet another expansion of government in the business of paying for health-care services.

Hadley Heath Manning is the director of health policy for the Independent Women's Forum. Her work has been featured in The Wall Street Journal, Forbes, POLITICO, Roll Call, Real Clear Policy, National Review Online, and Huffington Post, among others. Manning is also the Tony Blankley Fellow at the Steamboat Institute.

]]>

How the Bernie Sanders Plan Would Both Beef Up and Slim Down Medicare .
The Medicare-for-all plan would mean not just an expansion but a redefinition of the program.In his big new single-payer health care bill, Senator Bernie Sanders says he wants to turn the country’s health system into “Medicare for all.” But his bill actually outlines a system very different from the current Medicare program.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks
This is interesting!