Technology Delays and safety concerns mar NASA’s plans to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft

18:02  18 january  2018
18:02  18 january  2018 Source:   theverge.com

NASA is going back to the moon — if it can figure out how to get there

  NASA is going back to the moon — if it can figure out how to get there The Trump Administration steers NASA toward moon, the third major pivot for the agency this centuryNASA put 12 astronauts on the moon between 1969 and 1972. With the death Friday of Apollo 16’s John Young, only five of those astronauts are still alive, and they range in age from 82 to 87. No human being has been beyond low Earth orbit since the end of the Apollo program.

NASA ’ s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays , as well as questions regarding the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t happy about it.

0. 260. SHARES. Facebook Twitter. SpaceX and Boeing still have a long road ahead to crewed flights. NASA ’ s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays

Artistic renderings of SpaceX and Boeing’s Commercial Crew spacecraft.  © Provided by The Verge Artistic renderings of SpaceX and Boeing’s Commercial Crew spacecraft.  NASA’s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays, as well as questions regarding the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t happy about it.

Members of the House Subcommittee on Space held a hearing on Wednesday in which they grilled representatives from NASA and its commercial partners about the program, known as Commercial Crew. They voiced concerns that the commercial vehicles might put human crew members at risk, and that the companies will miss crucial deadlines by two to three years.

See Jupiter Looking Downright Gorgeous in These New NASA Photos

  See Jupiter Looking Downright Gorgeous in These New NASA Photos NASA has shared brand new photos of Jupiter taken by the Juno spacecraft, showing the gas giant’s blue-tinged skies. The Juno spacecraft takes batches of photos about every 53 days as it orbits Jupiter. NASA has shared brand new photos of Jupiter taken by the Juno spacecraft, showing the gas giant’s blue-tinged skies.

NASA ’ s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays , as well as questions regarding the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t happy about it.

As part of the program, two companies — Boeing and SpaceX — are developing spacecraft to ferry NASA astronauts to and from the International Space Station. When these two companies were selected by NASA back in 2014, the goal was to start flying crews to the station as early as 2017. But 2017 has come and gone, and the target dates keep moving. Just this month, SpaceX’s timeline for its first Commercial Crew flight was pushed back four months, and NASA says both companies are still a year away from flying astronauts for the first time.

Congress isn’t happy about it

Experts think that’s a generous expectation. Wednesday's hearing coincided with the release of a critical report on the Commercial Crew program from the Government Accountability Office, which does periodic audits of NASA’s agendas.

SpaceX Dragon Capsule Returns to Earth After Space Station Delivery

  SpaceX Dragon Capsule Returns to Earth After Space Station Delivery A SpaceX Dragon cargo ship left the International Space Station and returned to Earth Saturday (Jan. 13), wrapping up a nearly month-long delivery mission for NASA that also marked the spacecraft's second trip to space.The uncrewed Dragon supply ship detached from the space station's robotic arm at 4:58 a.m. EST (0958 GMT) and began firing thrusters for its return to Earth. The space capsule splashed down in the Pacific Ocean off the coast of Baja California to be retrieved by SpaceX, the company announced at 10:39 a.m. EST (1539 GMT).

NASA ’ s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays , as well as questions regarding the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t happy about it.

NASA ’ s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays , as well as questions regarding the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t happy about it.

The authors of the report claim that SpaceX won’t be certified to fly astronauts to the ISS until December 2019, while Boeing’s certification will happen in February 2020. NASA plans to certify the company’s vehicles only after it has done an uncrewed test flight and a crewed test flight, meaning the first astronauts likely won’t fly until late next year at the earliest. The vehicles can only start performing regular trips to the ISS once they’re certified.

The report also raises doubts that Boeing and SpaceX will meet the safety standards that NASA has set for the program. NASA is requiring that both companies prove that there is only a 1 in 270 chance of a flight going catastrophically wrong and losing crew members on board. In other words, 99.6 percent of the Commercial Crew missions should keep astronauts safe during flight.

It’s a particularly stringent requirement, especially since each space shuttle flight had a 1 in 80 chance of loss of life. The GAO report argues that the two companies may not meet this hard standard, and that NASA may have to accept a higher level of risk for the astronauts on board.

5 NASA Photos Of The Solar System’s Less Famous Moons

  5 NASA Photos Of The Solar System’s Less Famous Moons These moons don’t get a lot of attention but they have weird shapes and other cool features. © Photo: NASA/JPL Saturn's moon Atlas looks like a flying saucer in this new image from NASA's Cassini spacecraft. Titan and Enceladus are the royalty of Saturn’s moon population, which would make Atlas more like a peasant. Orbiting just outside the planet’s bright A ring, it is smaller than 20 miles across and wasn’t even discovered until 1980. But this moon is unique because of its shape: It looks like an alien saucer. NASA released photos of Atlas earlier this year that show off that strange structure.

NASA ’ s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays , as well as questions regarding the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t happy about it.

NASA ’ s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays , as well as questions regarding the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t happy about it. Experts think that’s a generous expectation.

But Congress is refusing to give NASA and its commercial partners any more wiggle room. The subcommittee members made it clear that NASA should not expect more money to help the companies meet their deadlines, and that changing the safety standards is not a good idea.

“Both companies are making progress, but certainly not at the rate that was expected, and not without significant challenges to safety and reliability,” Rep. Brian Babin (R-Texas), chairman of the House Subcommittee on Space, said at the hearing. “In order to remedy these problems, NASA may seek additional funding or accept significant risks. Neither of those options is viable.”

The Commercial Crew program was originally envisioned as a more cost-effective way to develop new vehicles for NASA. Instead of NASA investing billions and heavily overseeing the development of a spacecraft — as it did with the shuttle — the space agency would let commercial companies develop their own vehicles with minimal oversight and partial government funding. 

The idea was that this more “hands off” approach would save taxpayers’ money and allow companies more flexibility when creating their vehicles. The companies could also conceivably work faster, since they wouldn’t be restricted by as much government red tape.

First Asteroid Ever Discovered Is Actually A Dwarf Planet

  First Asteroid Ever Discovered Is Actually A Dwarf Planet The astronomers who discovered the first asteroid, the dwarf planet Ceres, had a hard time figuring it out.The first asteroid discovered in the solar system took an entire year to nail down. It was Ceres, the largest object in the asteroid belt.

NASA ’ s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays , as well as questions regarding the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t happy about it.

NASA ’ s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays , as well as questions regarding the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t happy about it.

While it’s true that NASA is saving potentially millions of dollars by investing in these commercial vehicles, the Commercial Crew program isn’t moving as quickly as expected. One reason may be that the companies set super aggressive target dates (something the GAO notes in its report).

The strict safety standards may also play a roll, requiring the companies to do lots of additional testing to prove that their vehicles are reliable and safe. Plus, other unforeseen challenges have cropped up, throwing timelines off track.

NASA says that ultimately, the schedule isn’t the agency’s biggest priority.

The SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket launches from the Space Launch Complex 4 at Vandenberg Air Force Base in Lompoc, California, on Dec. 22. © Getty The SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket launches from the Space Launch Complex 4 at Vandenberg Air Force Base in Lompoc, California, on Dec. 22. “NASA is aware of the schedule but not driven by the schedule,” Bill Gerstenmaier, associate administrator for Human Exploration and Operations for NASA, said at the hearing.

Of course, as the dates for the program move to the right, NASA continues its reliance on Russia to send U.S. astronauts to space. Currently, NASA astronauts can only fly on Russia’s Soyuz rocket to get to the ISS, and the space agency has already purchased extra Soyuz seats through 2019 because of delays in Commercial Crew. Additionally, the ISS program is only slated to last through 2024 at the moment, meaning the commercial vehicles may not be transporting astronauts for very long.

Christa McAuliffe's lost lessons finally taught in space

  Christa McAuliffe's lost lessons finally taught in space Christa McAuliffe's lost lessons are finally getting taught in space. Thirty-two years after the Challenger disaster, a pair of teachers turned astronauts will pay tribute to McAuliffe by carrying out her science classes on the International Space Station.

NASA ’ s ambitious initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to suffer from schedule delays , as well as questions regarding the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t happy about it.

NASA ’ s bold initiative to fly astronauts on commercial spacecraft continues to be afflicted by time table delays , in addition to questions in regards to the program’s safety — and Congress isn’t glad about it.

Both the authors of the GAO report and members of Congress agree that safety should be the top priority, and that’s why lots of questions were raised at the hearing on Wednesday regarding SpaceX’s launch record. Congress members repeatedly asked if SpaceX’s recent classified Zuma mission failed, as some reports have indicated, and if the company was to blame.

“We relayed the information that Falcon 9 performed as specified, and it actually performed very well as specified,” Hans Koenigsmann, vice president of Build and Flight Reliability at SpaceX, said at the hearing.

Concerns about the Falcon 9

The subcommittee also brought up SpaceX’s failure from 2016, in which one of the company’s Falcon 9 rockets exploded while it was being loaded with propellant. Safety experts have been on edge about the failure, since SpaceX wants astronauts to board the rocket before the propellant is loaded — which could pose a safety hazard.

SpaceX insists that this method will be safe and that its abort system will be able to safely carry crew members away from a malfunctioning rocket. Additionally, NASA’s Gerstenmaier is still looking at the best time to put people on SpaceX’s vehicles.

Meanwhile, Boeing has its own problems with its abort system, which may not meet NASA’s safety standards, according to the GAO report. And there’s a risk that when the company’s vehicle falls back to Earth, part of the spacecraft’s heat shield might actually damage its parachutes. If NASA refuses to accept this possibility, then Boeing will likely need to redesign its parachutes, according to the GAO.

Addressing these problems will be a top priority for NASA as it moves forward with the program this year. At some point in 2018, the agency will need to decide what level of risk it’s willing to accept for the program, despite Congress’ misgivings — and that means potentially more delays are on the horizon.

Despite the negativity from the GAO report and hearing, however, one member of the subcommittee offered some praise and hope for Commercial Crew.

“So it looks like the program is going along as we thought it would, even though there have been glitches,” Rep. Dana Rohrabacher (R-Calif.) said at the hearing. “But there are the glitches in the development of any new technology.”

Spunky Mars Rover snaps a new selfie .
<p>NASA's popular Mars Curiosity Rover has sent back a new selfie from the red planet.&nbsp;</p>"I'm back! Did you miss me?" the rover (well, actually its social media team) tweeted.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!