US National School Walkout: do students have First Amendment rights at school?
Students plan abortion protest after debate on walkout
Students at a California high school are organizing an anti-abortion rights protest that was inspired by the recent nationwide student walkout for gun control. Rocklin High School student Brandon Gillespie tells KOVR-TV he wants to "honor all the lives of aborted babies" with the protest.He says the idea was prompted by history teacher Julianne Benzel. She was placed on administrative leave when she asked students to consider whether there was a double standard over protests on school grounds between gun control and abortion.
The First Amendment gives students some free-speech protections.
Students at more thanacross the United States are planning to walk out of class at 10 am in each time zone Wednesday to protest congressional inaction on gun control.
The National School Walkout will be a, in honor of the 17 people who died in the in Parkland, Florida, last month. The walkout is being organized by Youth Empower, a division of the national Women’s March group.
Missouri high school students marked truant, punished for participating in walkout: report
Students at a Kansas City, Mo. high school who participated in a walkout to protest gun violence on Wednesday were marked truant and punished. Only about 200 of Park Hill High School's 2,000-person student body participated in the walkout as part of a larger series of student-led protests organized across the country, Fox 4 News in Kansas City reported.But students were warned against doing so by teachers. Those that did participate were greeted by teachers in the school's hallways when they returned.
The protest aimsto raise awareness of the students’ demands for gun control before a march later this month in Washington, DC. The demands include banning assault-style weapons and expanding background checks to all gun buyers.
Because the walkout is scheduled during school hours, it has triggered confusion about how teachers andprincipals should respond. Do students have a right to protest when they should be in class? And are schools allowed to punish students who participate?
Gallery by photo services
Part of the confusion stems from the fact that the answer to both those questions is “yes, to some extent.” Students at public schools have a right to express their political views, but schools have the right to place limits on how they express those views to ensure they don’t disrupt the learning process. Schools can even suspend students in some cases (more on that below).
Civil liberties groups are worried that some schools might be going too far in their punishment threats — potentially infringing on students’ constitutional rights. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) in Nevada warned school administrators across the state about this last week after hearing reports that some had threatened to withhold students’ diplomas and kick students off sports teams for participating in the walkout.
“These forms of punishment far exceed those permitted by statute and are constitutionally suspect,” the ACLU of Nevadato students.
Not all schools are responding the same way. Some, such as, have chosen to help students plan their walkout. A high school principal in , will excuse students who miss class to protest. Others have decided not to get involved in any way.
Here are a few things to understand about a student’s right to protest at school.
Schools can punish students, but not for expressing their political views
It’s completely legal for a school district — or even a state — to discipline students for an unexcused absence if that is school policy. Students under 18 are required by law to go to school in most states, so they can be punished for missing class. But punishment can vary from state to state and from school district to school district. One school might not consider a 17-minute walkout an unexcused absence, while another one might. One school might not suspend students for unexcused absences, while another one would.
For students deciding whether to take part in the walkout, the ACLUthem to check their school’s policies for missing class.
But let’s say that a school district allows its students to participate in the walkout without punishment. Are there any limits to how students can express their views as part of the protest?
In 1969, the US Supreme Court ruled unequivocally that students at public schools do not “shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech and expression at the school house gate.” The landmark case, Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District, involved a 13-year-old girl from Des Moines, Mary Beth Tinker, who was suspended for wearing a black armband to protest the Vietnam War.
In the Court’s decision, the justices said that school administrators cannot punish students merely for expressing political views. They can only discipline students if their speech or actions cause “material” or “substantial” disruption to school functions.
This is important in the context of the national walkout. Does a mass walkout qualify asa “substantial” disruption in the school? That’s a call school officials would have to make. But they would have to show that the walkout made it impossible for school staff to do their jobs or for teachers to continue their lessons with those who stayed in class.
Furthermore, the school cannot impose a punishment that goes beyond usual school policy. For example, principals can’t suspend students for three days for participating in the walkout if the district’s usual policy is to give students a written reprimand for skipping class. Anything more than that would suggest that the school is punishing students for expressing their political views, which is a violation of their constitutional rights.
“If an unexcused absence leads to a three-day suspension, that is going to raise eyebrows,” said Ben Wizner, director of the ACLU’s Speech, Privacy, and Technology Project.
That’s not the same situation at public universities, where students can join the walkout without threat of punishment.
“The law can’t require college students to go to college,” said Wizner. “But there could be academic consequences for missing class.”
Onething to keep in mind is that students at private schools and universities do not have First Amendment protections on campus. The First Amendment prohibits only government censorship of political views and other protected forms of speech.
That’s why students at private institutions are not covered by the same protections as students in public schools. “Students at private schools don’t have the same liberties,” Wizner told me.
Teachers don’t have a right to join the national walkout
Teachers at public schools do have some free speech protections, but they’re not quite as protected as students.
Basically, teachers are expected to teach during school hours. They can attend a school board meeting and protest a proposal to arm teachers, Wizner says, but they don't necessarily have a right to protest when they’re supposed to be teaching class.
It’s reasonable for school principals to order them to stay in class during the walkout. School administrators could also ask some teachers to walk out with the students to supervise them (not to protest themselves).
But just as a school cannot ban a student’s political speech, it also cannot force students to participate in a protest. Students have the right to stay in class and keep learning if they want to, so a school cannot order everyone to join the walkout.
“It works both ways,” Wizner says.
If a teacher is asked to supervise students during the walkout, he or she must have someone in class with the students who don’t want to take part.
To punish, or not to punish
While schools have every right todiscipline protesting students for unexcused absences consistent with school policy, they might see value in encouraging civic engagement or political debate among students and choose not to punish them.
That’s what happened in Missoula, Montana, when students at Hellgate High School walked out of school on February 21 in solidarity with students in Parkland.
The principal, Judson Miller, toldthat while the school could not endorse the protest, he wanted to make it a safe space for students who decided to take part in it. He said he told staff to use it as a teachable moment.
”This is a real opportunity for students to demonstrate responsibility,” he told the newspaper. “If I give you a lot of responsibility, you need to help peer monitor each other.”
Per school policy, administrators notified the parents of students who missed class.
Schools in Arizona responded more harshly to another recent walkout. Dozens of students at Ingleside Middle School, in the Phoenix area, gotafter they left campus on February 27 to protest gun violence.
That doesn’t seem to have discouraged other students from participating in Wednesday’s protest. Students atand in the Phoenix area have planned to join the walkout.
Sister of South Carolina mass shooter arrested on weapons charges .
The sister of avowed white supremacist Dylann Roof, who was sentenced to die for the 2015 massacre at a historic South Carolina black church, was arrested on Wednesday for carrying weapons at a high school, media said. Morgan Roof, 18, was carrying a knife and pepper spray, as well as marijuana, at a school in Columbia, S.C., the Post and Courier and other media reported.The arrest came on the morning of a protest walkout by thousands of students nationwide to demand gun law reform in the wake of a Florida mass shooting that killed 14 students and 3 teachers a month ago.
Students! Know Your Protest Rights (with the ACLU)
Students around the country are turning last week's heartbreaking school shooting in Parkland, Florida, into an inspiring push for change. Plans for coordinated student walkouts have been...
If you're planning to take part in the national school walkout, read this
(CNN)Students across the country are expected to walk out of their classrooms Wednesday morning to protest gun violence. The National School Walkout is scheduled to begin at 10 a.m. in every...
Friday, 23 march 2018
At least four people have died in this nor'easter that brought snow, poor visibility and slippery conditions to the Mid-Atlantic and Northeast.The death toll from the fourth nor'easter in three weeks to slam the Northeast stood at four Thursday as millions of Americans dug out and […]
Thursday, 22 march 2018
The 23-year-old recorded a message on his phone that officials described as an “outcry.”People who knew him say Conditt was quiet and […]
Thursday, 22 march 2018
The pastor, Andy Savage, said he made a mistake in how he first addressed the allegations from Jules Woodson in January. He left his position at Highpoint Church this week.The decision by the pastor, Andy Savage, 42, came on the same day that Highpoint Church said it had completed a […]
Friday, 23 march 2018
ANDERSON, Calif. - The two young, blond women in figure-flattering ball gowns hoisted whiskey and shotguns. An auctioneer rattled off bids. Above the stage in the banquet hall hung a green flag for the 51st state of Jefferson, with its pair of Xs called a "double-cross" […]
Police shot and killed an unarmed black man in his own backyard. All he was holding was a cellphone.Thursday, 22 march 2018
Officers say they mistook Stephon Clark’s cellphone for a gun. Activists want more answers. Police killings of unarmed black men helped fuel the rise of the Black Lives Matter Movement. Now a new tragedy — the shooting death of an unarmed black man in his own backyard — is raising new […]
Thursday, 22 march 2018
Some on social media asked: Would the Austin bombing suspect be characterized in the same way if he had been a person of color?Load […]
Thursday, 22 march 2018
The teen who terrorized his Maryland high school used his father's gun to shoot an ex-girlfriend and a classmate. The Maryland teenager who terrorized his high school used his father's handgun to shoot a girl he'd just broken up with and another classmate, investigators said […]
Thursday, 22 march 2018
Another Bill O'Reilly accuser has filed a defamation lawsuit against the former Fox News star. Laurie Dhue alleges in new court documents that O'Reilly mounted a "smear campaign" against her after the New York Times reported last April she received a $1 million settlement related to […]