The page you are looking for is temporarily unavailable.
Please try again later

US A Hate Crime? How the Charlottesville Car Attack May Become a Federal Case

02:30  14 august  2017
02:30  14 august  2017 Source:   nytimes.com

Charlottesville suspect held hate group shield before attack

  Charlottesville suspect held hate group shield before attack James Fields Jr., the maniac driver who police say steered his beloved Dodge Challenger into a crowd of peaceful protesters, had been brandishing a shield emblazoned with a white supremacist emblem just hours before the deadly rampage. The Daily News photographed Fields on the front lines of a volatile rally about 10:30 a.m. Saturday in Charlottesville — flanked by other white men in polo shirts and tan slacks clutching the racially charged black-and-white insignia of the Vanguard America hate group.

The hate crimes statute gives federal prosecutors the opportunity to bring a case if a defendant attacked a victim because of certain But portraying the attack in Charlottesville that way could help enable federal jurisdiction for what would normally be the state crime of vehicular manslaughter.

The hate crimes statute gives federal prosecutors the opportunity to bring a case if a defendant attacked a victim because of certain characteristics, such as the victim’s race, religion, national origin, ethnicity, gender or sexual orientation. How Charlottesville became a flashpoint 8mth.

Attorney General Jeff Sessions during a news conference at the Justice Department this month.© Zach Gibson for The New York Times Attorney General Jeff Sessions during a news conference at the Justice Department this month.

WASHINGTON — The Justice Department’s announcement that it is opening a civil rights investigation into a deadly car crash into a crowd of people protesting white nationalists in Charlottesville, Va., has put a spotlight on what the department’s role may be under Attorney General Jeff Sessions.

Mr. Sessions was an outspoken conservative senator from Alabama before President Trump appointed him attorney general, and many civil rights advocates view him with suspicion. Under his stewardship, the department’s civil rights division has been pulling back on enforcement of laws on matters like voting rights and police reform.

Woman Killed in Charlottesville Was ‘Murdered While Protesting Hate’

  Woman Killed in Charlottesville Was ‘Murdered While Protesting Hate’ She has been identified as Heather Heyer, 32.The crash left Heyer lying on the pavement alongside another victim, the Daily News reports. It’s not clear if she died at the scene or not.

Related Coverage. A Hate Crime ? How the Charlottesville Car Attack May Become a Federal Case AUG.

Not all crimes motivated by hate are covered by the federal hate crimes law. How the Charlottesville Car Attack May Become a Federal Case AUG.

But when the department announced the civil rights investigation late Saturday, it included a forceful statement from Mr. Sessions: “The violence and deaths in Charlottesville strike at the heart of American law and justice. When such actions arise from racial bigotry and hatred, they betray our core values and cannot be tolerated.”

Sign Up For the Morning Briefing Newsletter

State law enforcement officials have primary jurisdiction to prosecute James Alex Fields Jr., 20, whom they have charged with second-degree murder in an attack that killed Heather D. Heyer of Charlottesville and injured at least 19 other people. But the department’s announcement raises the question of whether Mr. Sessions could also seek to make it a federal case.

Mother Of Charlottesville Victim Heather Heyer: 'I’m Proud Of What She Did'

  Mother Of Charlottesville Victim Heather Heyer: 'I’m Proud Of What She Did' <p>Heather, a paralegal who lived in Charlottesville, was determined to stand up to injustice, her mother told HuffPost.</p><p></p>She was thinking fondly of her daughter, 32-year-old Heather Heyer, who was killed in Charlottesville, Virginia the day before after a man drove his car into protesters of the “Unite the Right” rally, a gathering of white supremacist groups.

WASHINGTON — The Justice Department’s announcement that it is opening a civil rights investigation into a deadly car crash into a crowd of people protesting white nationalists in Charlottesville , Virginia, has put a spotlight on what the department’s role may be under Attorney Genera.

A Hate Crime ? How the Charlottesville Car Attack May Become a Federal Case . Suspect in Charlottesville Car Attack Is Denied Bail in Court Appearance.

Is this considered a hate crime?

Not necessarily. Just because a crime was motivated by hate does not mean it is covered by the federal hate crimes law. Only particular types of hatred count. The hate crimes statute gives federal prosecutors the opportunity to bring a case if a defendant attacked a victim because of certain characteristics, such as the victim’s race, religion, national origin, ethnicity, gender or sexual orientation.

The hate crimes law traces to the Civil Rights Act of 1968 and has been expanded since. When Congress expanded it to include sexual orientation and gender identity in 2009, Mr. Sessions opposed the move, arguing that state criminal laws against assault and murder were sufficient. But as attorney general he has vowed to enforce it.

Still, it may be difficult to prove that Mr. Fields was motivated by one of the characteristics protected by the hate crimes statute, like race; hatred of people because of their political views is not specifically mentioned in the law. Although several of the surviving victims are black, Ms. Heyer was white.

Trump Complains Media Not 'Satisfied' By Belated Denunciation Of Hate Groups

  Trump Complains Media Not 'Satisfied' By Belated Denunciation Of Hate Groups President Donald Trump on Monday evening complained the “fake news media will never be truly satisfied” by his belated denunciation of white supremacists and other hate groups, two days after violence erupted after a rally in Charlottesville, Virginia.“Made additional remarks on Charlottesville and realize once again that the #Fake News Media will never be satisfied,” Trump tweeted. “Truly bad people!”Made additional remarks on Charlottesville and realize once again that the #Fake News Media will never be satisfied…truly bad people!— Donald J.

How the Charlottesville Car Attack May Become a Federal Case AUG. A Hate Crime ?

Charlottesville , Va., car attack could be considered a hate crime , NBC News reported Wednesday. Sessions added that officials have not decided whether Fields would be tried in federal or state court.

What about the Ku Klux Klan Act?

Tracing to a law enacted in 1871, the so-called Ku Klux Klan Act criminalizes certain types of politically motivated violence that today would be called terrorism. Some of its provisions require evidence of conspiracy, so they would apply only if investigators turn up evidence that the attacker plotted with others, rather than spontaneously decided to commit violence. One notable provision, however, can cover a defendant who acted alone.

A provision added as part of the Civil Rights Act, Section 245 of Title 18, makes it a federal crime to use force to willfully injure or intimidate any citizen because the victim was “participating lawfully in speech or peaceful assembly” opposing the denial of certain civil rights to other people, like a right to vote or receive service from a business that accommodates the public. If bodily injury results from the crime, each count can carry a 10-year prison sentence. If a victim is killed, prosecutors may seek life imprisonment or the death penalty.

Federal prosecutors might try to use this law, but it is not clear whether it would apply to people protesting a white nationalist rally. Justin Levitt, a law professor at Loyola Law School, Los Angeles, who was a deputy in the Justice Department’s civil rights division during the Obama administration, said there was scant guiding precedent about whether the statute covered something like the attack in Charlottesville.

Man recounts pushing fiancee away from car during protest

  Man recounts pushing fiancee away from car during protest With tires screeching and bodies flying, Marcus Martin shoved his fiancee out of the way of a car charging through a crowd of peaceful protesters in Charlottesville, Virginia. Marcus Martin was promptly hit and upended by the car as it plowed through the crowd. Flat on his back with a broken leg, he says he experienced several minutes of terror."The only thing running through my mind was: please don't let her be dead," Martin, 26, told The Associated Press in an interview. "Please don't let her be dead.

Experts say the incident might straddle the line between terrorism and a hate crime . Attorney General Jeff Sessions said Monday that the fatal car attack in Charlottesville meets the definition of domestic terrorism, echoing calls from Republican and Democratic lawmakers and former federal

Experts say the incident might straddle the line between terrorism and a hate crime . A memorial at the site of the deadly car attack in Charlottesville . A part of how federal authorities proceed in Charlottesville might focus on what the Justice Department wants to say to the public about what

“You don’t often see someone ramming a car into a peaceful protest,” he said. “The sorts of things you see in Charlottesville, you don’t see often.”

Was this domestic terrorism?

Lisa Monaco, the former head of the Justice Department’s national security division and a former counterterrorism and Homeland Security adviser to President Barack Obama, raised the question of whether the federal government should be handling the investigation as a domestic terrorist attack.

“I think the biggest question is whether the F.B.I. is going to investigate this as a domestic terrorism case, given the presence of groups that have been the subject of such investigations before or would meet their criteria, like the K.K.K., and the nature of the attack,” she said. “A guy plowed his car into a crowd of protesters — that kind of violence, committed for seeming political ends, is the very definition of domestic terrorism.”

Under federal law that was expanded by the U.S.A. Patriot Act after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, a violation of federal or state criminal law qualifies as “domestic terrorism” if it appears to be intended to coerce or intimidate a civilian population or to coerce the policy of the government.

Domestic terrorism is not, itself, a criminal offense that prosecutors could charge. But portraying the attack in Charlottesville that way could help enable federal jurisdiction for what would normally be the state crime of vehicular manslaughter. It could also trigger certain enhanced powers to obtain records or seize assets that are available in security investigations. Since Virginia has the death penalty, however, federalizing the prosecution might not trigger any greater set of penalties for a conviction.

It is not clear whether the department will decide to classify the Charlottesville investigation that way. In its statement announcing the civil rights investigation, the department said, “The F.B.I. will collect all available facts and evidence, and as this is an ongoing investigation, we are not able to comment further at this time.”

Follow Charlie Savage on Twitter @charlie_savage.

Friend of Charlottesville Victim Heather Heyer Recounts Horror of Attack: 'It Happened in a Second' .
A former co-worker of Heather Heyer‘s recounted to PEOPLE the tragic events of Aug. 12, when Heyer was killed by a driver who rammed his car into a group of counter-protesters demonstrating against a white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia.&nbsp; A former co-worker of Heather Heyer‘s recounted to PEOPLE the tragic events of Aug. 12, when Heyer was killed by a driver who rammed his car into a group of counter-protesters demonstrating against a white supremacist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!